Thursday, September 17, 2009

Review on Seth Godin and Clay Shirky from TED.com

   The two videos were definitely similar by touching on how technology is making history by streamlining the process in which we share information and bring people together. Seth Godin was describing how different "tribes" use the Internet to make it possible for someone to join a group and connect with others. This happens when, say, someone who lives in the U.S. makes a social connection with people in Italy and Russia who share the same interests. What Seth points at in this is that only through the Internet is this even a possibility. Clay Shirky had similar views, focusing on the idea that these jumps in the evolution of technology have lead to the point where the world is brought together in a way never seen before. With the use of instant video streaming, the citizens of China could override the Chinese government and release a raw and unfiltered view of the damage done to them following the earthquake. What is really interesting is that both speakers suggested that the increasing speed at which we communicate is amazing and has completely transformed today's social network.
   The difference between the videos was Godin had heavy focus on people in terms of interest groups and how social life has broken through for connecting people who seem to search for others like them while Clay took a broader look at how anyone with a camera and a computer could make history by uploading very recent or current events of breaking news. Godin takes this idea of a "tribe" to a new level by completely dissolving the boudaries of physical placement when it comes to people of similar interest connecting. Since physical placement used to be almost essential for any group to function, now people can share with one another from anywhere, at anytime, instantly. Clay shows how the control that was once present over people on the filtration of information is now incredibly permeable. Since the government cant control people from getting information out, who says that this cant happen in many other instances? Maybe evidence used against people could change. Now once you post a video file online , anyone could have a copy and if there were attempts to cover up the evidence it would be nearly impossible because others could copy and duplicate once the file is shared (this assumes that the video is being saved and shared to others computers, I don't know these things work). This also means that much consideration will need to be taken with the ways the world traditonally works with sharing digital info. If not careful, people could make quite a mess as far as control, communication, and even privacy as concerned.

3 comments:

  1. Great writing, its funny to think how technology has really evolved over the years. Even when we were younger and the use of cell phones wasn't as popular as now, and to think that people are constantly updating there Facebook, Myspace, and Twitter while on the go in the blink of a second, really does change how we socially interact with one another. Your writing makes me want to look up your article and source and watch it for myself. Excellent point about media information such as video and pictures about how easy it is for them to pop up and how hard it is to get them down offline. Overall great job.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I loved your analysis. You showed some great opinions and ideas. The only thing I would have liked is a very brief general summary in the beginning. It almost felt like I was just dropped into the middle of a conversation.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nice analysis here! These videos seem really interesting, specially considering we are taking this class online. I particularly like your description of the Godin video, it was very interesting and well worded.
    But I agree with Sara that an introduction could make this piece better, considering you mention "the two videos" in your first line and the audience doesn't know exactly what videos you are referring to.
    Great job anyway, I'm actually going to search for those videos now.

    ReplyDelete